Self-Assessment Skills

How to Use This

This is a set of questions, not a test. Nothing is scored, nothing is recorded, and there is no result to report to anyone. The point is to give you an honest read on where you actually are, because the most common pattern we see is people who are either more confident than their habits justify, or considerably more capable than they give themselves credit for.

Work through the three sets below in order. Stop at the first set where you find yourself saying “not really” more than once — that is where your next effort is best spent, and the link at the end of each section points to it.

Where Are You?

Ask yourself honestly:

  • Can I explain, in one sentence and without using the word “learns,” what a generative AI tool is doing when it answers me?
  • Have I used one for something real, not just to see what it does?
  • When I get an answer I do not like, do I tell the tool what was wrong with it — or do I give up, or accept it?
  • Do I know what I should never type into one of these tools?
  • Could I name one task in my week where AI would genuinely help, and one where it would be the wrong choice?

If several of these are “not really”: start with Foundational Skills. It is short and it covers exactly these.

If these are all comfortable: move to Set 2.

This set is about the habits that separate routine use from reliable use.

  • When AI gives me a citation, do I open it — every time, not just when it looks odd?
  • Have I ever caught the tool being confidently wrong? (If you never have, you are probably not checking.)
  • Do I ask for criticism of my work explicitly, knowing that “any feedback?” will get me compliments?
  • Do I give it my actual documents to work from, rather than relying on what it already knows?
  • Could I explain to a colleague, a student, or a supervisor exactly how I used AI on a piece of work and why I trust the result?
  • Do I notice when the output has drifted into generic AI prose, and fix it?

If several are “not really”: Critical Evaluation Skills is the highest-value page on this site for you. The verification habit is the single thing most regular users are missing.

If these are comfortable: move to Set 3.

  • Do I reuse prompts I have refined, rather than rewriting the same request from scratch?
  • Do I break large tasks into steps I can inspect, instead of asking for the finished thing?
  • Do I know which of my tasks are genuinely better done without AI, and do I actually skip the tool for those?
  • When I build something others will use, do I know what review it might need — data handling, accessibility, records — before I build it?
  • Can I help a colleague who is stuck, including telling them when AI is the wrong answer to their problem?
  • Do I have a defensible position on the ethical questions in my own field, rather than an unexamined one?

If several are “not really”: Advanced Skills covers the first three, and Choosing the Right Tool covers the fourth.

If these are all comfortable: you are in a position to help other people, and the ARC would genuinely like to hear from you — see Support Channels.

A Few Honest Cautions

Confidence is not the same as capability. The people most likely to be surprised by this page are heavy users who have never verified an AI citation. Comfort with a tool builds quickly; the judgment about when to distrust it does not build on its own.

Neither is caution the same as ignorance. People who have deliberately stayed away from these tools often turn out to have sound instincts about them and need only a small amount of practical grounding.

You do not need to reach Set 3. For many roles, Sets 1 and 2 are entirely sufficient. Depth is worth pursuing when your work calls for it, not as a goal in itself.

Where to Go Next